^Update: Eli makes his case for Canton

[Reveryroadie]

Originally Posted by mrtxstar

One thing you can always count on Eli for is being inconsistant. If he's been good, the bad Eli is just around the corner. He's done this his whole career so don't expect that to change. It's funny to me how giants fans can so easily forget about this. He plays great sometimes, and for that he is to be commended but he isn't consistant enough to EVER be considered elite.

we can say the same thing about Tony Romo. the difference is Eli has 2 rings and Romo has none. so Eli has to be more consistant.

[mrtxstar]

Originally Posted by Reveryroadie

we can say the same thing about Tony Romo. the difference is Eli has 2 rings and Romo has none. so Eli has to be more consistant.

Why is your benchmark the Dallas Cowboys? You should stop making those comparisons. The Cowboys haven't done shit in over 16 years. Even if Eli is more consistant than Romo(and I'm not saying he is), that don't make him elite.

[Reaper]

mrtxstar is such a dick!

[mrtxstar]

Originally Posted by Reaper

mrtxstar is such a dick!

Is this how we roll at SJ when someones opinion differs from yours?

[Reaper]

Originally Posted by mrtxstar

Is this how we roll at SJ when someones opinion differs from yours?

No that is how I decided to roll at that moment and was chewed out by a member of the staff and given an official warning which I respect because I was wrong for posting that in public, should have done it privately. I stand on my own here at SJ, don't blame the wonderful members here for what I say!

[mrtxstar]

Originally Posted by Reaper

No that is how I decided to roll at that moment and was chewed out by a member of the staff and given an official warning which I respect because I was wrong for posting that in public, should have done it privately. I stand on my own here at SJ, don't blame the wonderful members here for what I say!

Reaper, I appreciate how passionate you are about your team. More times than not, we will disagree when it comes to NFL issues but we can not let that disagreement get personal. Nothing I say is ever intended to be a personal attack and I try to never put my words in that context. You can say anything you want about the Cowboys and promise I will never take it personally. I can't even defend them this year and you may notice I haven't tried. But rest assured, next season...I'll be sporting Cowboy swag. Did you notice the first person to give you props on your article about your father/son SB experience? That's right, it was me. I don't dislike you bro, and I'm not trying to make you dislike me. I'm just a guy with an opinion.

[Reaper]

Thought this was way too funny not not share!